Man of Taste

In 1954, culture critic Russell Lynes published “The Tastemakers: The Shaping of American Popular Taste,” a lengthy meditation on the nature of taste, which Lynes believed had supplanted class as the new social hierarchy. Taste, Lynes argues, can be broken into three categories: Highbrow, Middlebrow and Lowbrow. Naturally the theory applies to clothing. A supplementary chart in “The Tastemakers” includes the following sartorial hierarchy:

Highbrow: Fuzzy Harris Tweed suit in town, same in country.

Upper Middlebrow: Brooks Brothers suit and rep tie in town, tweed jacket and knit tie in country.

Lower Middlebrow: Double-breasted suit and “splashy” tie in city, sport shirt and colored slacks in country.

Lowbrow: “Loafer” jacket and woven shoes in town, old army clothes in country.

In a 1983 interview in American Heritage, Lynes updated his opinion. Tweed was no longer highbrow. That’s understandable. What’s odd is that madras had fallen all the way to lower middlebrow. Where are these bowling teams in matching madras jackets?

Q: For highbrow clothes, you had fuzzy tweeds and no hat. What now?

A: The tweed thing I will change. Turtlenecks and jeans now; jeans, or Levi’s corduroys, like the ones I have on this moment. Terribly comfortable, and they last forever.

Q: Apparently exposing you as a highbrow in the matter of pants. Now, what about clothing for the upper middlebrow?

A: I think blazer and gray flannels. Or plain jacket and loud pants.

Q: Lower-middlebrow clothes?

A: What would you say to a Madras jacket?

For a complementary (and more contemporary) study of the nature of taste, check out Stephen Bayley’s 1992 book “Taste: The Secret Meaning of Things.” Perplexing at times, raising as many questions as it answers, it’s still an insightful exploration of the sociology of taste.

Lynes is pictured above and below in 1959. Images three and four are from 1952 and 1949. — CC


7 Comments on "Man of Taste"

  1. Again, an outstanding posting.

    Thanks.

  2. Let’s not forget that these were the 80s. A google image search on the phrase “80s used car salesman” yields the following beauties:

    http://preview.tinyurl.com/64fwxq8

    http://preview.tinyurl.com/6jogwqx

    And my favorite: http://preview.tinyurl.com/6bytnab

    How this happened, I do not know. In fact, until I encountered Ivy Style, I always thought that the archetypal used car salesman was wearing clothing that was a throwback to 50s wool plaids; however, I would guess now that in fact he was coming late to the game, in the late 70s and early 80s, of trying to look monied and leisured to show that he had a successful business. By that time, prior to the OPH, he simply looked cheap and out of date. Especially with those lapels.

  3. Vern Trotter | February 24, 2019 at 6:06 pm |

    His father was an Episcopal priest. His quote, “Why would anyone want to live on Park Avenue?” was celebrated at the time, for some reason.

  4. My wife and I were good friends of his late daughter and son-in-law in Chicago
    in the seventies when her husband and I were graduate students at the U of Chicago.
    Later she became Commissioner of Planning in the administration of Mayor
    Harold Washington. Her style, “nondescript appropriate”. Not as WASPY as one might
    expect from a Bryn Mawr graduate.

  5. Kilgore Hofstadtler | February 25, 2019 at 5:34 am |

    No discourse on this matter is complete without reference to Paul Fussell’s classic book, Class.

  6. René Lebenthal | February 25, 2019 at 12:52 pm |

    Christian,
    Funnily all the pictures disappeared again. Only für european Ivy Style readers?

  7. Tech guy wants to know what browser you’re using, and to test in multiple browsers. Be sure and refresh a couple times in case they are loading a cached version from before without images.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*